The letter below is now with First Minister Nicola Sturgeon. No more signatures will be added, although you can still make a comment below this post. We will publish her response on this blog.
OPEN LETTER IN SUPPORT OF THE SCOTTISH POETRY LIBRARY
We, the undersigned, are writing to express our wholehearted support, and our gratitude, for the Scottish Poetry Library’s unequivocal stance defending free artistic expression for all who use its services. The Library is the first significant UK institution to make this stand for a fundamental democratic principle, in a climate which is increasingly hostile to any form of expression outside a very narrow ideology. From universities, to arts organisations, libraries and government departments, the no-platforming and bullying of anyone holding views not actively endorsing extreme gender ideology is destroying our cultural life. Scotland has always been an example of progressiveness in arts, education and culture, and we are proud that the first stand against this aggressive chilling of intellectual debate and thought has been taken by Scotland’s national poetry library. You are leading the way.
We believe that the open letter authored by Harry Josie Giles and others speaks for itself. However we would like to draw attention to the incorrect assertions in it, commonly used by activists to confuse and silence debate around what is the most divisive social issue of our time.
First, the sleight of hand by which the notion “women’s rights (which are transwomen’s rights)” is made to seem like an uncontroversial, even legal truth. It is not. Under equality law ‘sex’ is a protected characteristic, along with eight others. Gender identity is not one of them. ‘Trans’ is not even used as a term. ‘Gender reassignment’ is, but it is used in a completely different way than here, and still does not over-ride sex as a protected characteristic. This confusion over who and what is protected under equality law is being aggressively exploited by gender ideology activists to frighten institutions into believing they are breaking the law if they do not centre activist demands in all they do.
Second, gender activists refuse to understand the concept of ‘competing rights’. Women’s rights and the demands of gender activists are in conflict. This is why a proper debate is needed to explore and understand. The refusal to recognise this reveals what is really at hand: a determination to dominate and capture institutions with an ideology that is not enshrined in law but behaves as though it is, and is destroying our public institutions and cultural life.
Many of the undersigned have done so as women and same-sex attracted people deeply concerned by the threat to their rights presented by the blurring of definitions by gender ideology, such that ‘women’ and ‘sex’ become umbrella terms, and not specific descriptors to which specific rights attach. But, also, as writers, readers, and people who believe in free expression in a democracy, we are drawn to defend vigorously this assault on the language itself. The first step of an ideological takeover is to alter language to suit ideological aims. We all know our Orwell: meaning is the battle ground for freedom of thought. Make no mistake, this is what is being aggressively insinuated across our cultural life, which makes it even more courageous that the Scottish Poetry Library has stood up against it. Many of the signatories to this letter have had to do so anonymously or under pseudonyms. We are afraid for our reputations, our jobs, our livelihoods. This is how deeply this ideology has already travelled, that to speak against it is a danger.
We thank you, and hope you inspire other organisations to do the same.
@jeanrhys1 and @wwwritingclub
3rd March 2020
SIGNATORIES TO THE OPEN LETTER
Jane Harris, writer
Dr. Victoria Whitworth, Author, FSA, FSCA Scot
David Robinson, former Books Editor, The Scotsman
Dr. Shereen Benjamin, Senior Lecturer, University of Edinburgh
Joy Hendry, Author, Editor of Chapman magazine
Elizabeth Buccleuch
Catherine Czerkawska, Author
Lewis, Lord Moonie
Seven Hex
Marion Calder, co-founder forwomen.scot
J. David Simmons, Author
Dr. Louise Moody
Lynne MacDonald BSc, Glasgow University
Janice Edgar MA, Glasgow University
John McGowan
Cindy Douglas, Musician
Tabatha Stirling
Carole Leslie, Hon President QMU, 1983-1984
Rhona McGrath BSc, Glasgow University
Russell Walker, Director/Producer
Mark Graham, QMU President 1983-1984
Lionel Shriver, Author
Amanda Craig, Author
Helen Dale, Journalist
Russell Celyn Jones, Author
Joan Smith, Author
Dr. Mez Packer, Author
Kate Styles
Amanda Smyth, Author
Dr. Justin Hill, Author
Fiona Tresidder
Helen Joyce, journalist and writer
Graham Linehan, comedy writer
Sarah Fox
Ursula Hartlein
Karen Lee Stewart
Maria MacLachlan
Angela Buckley, Author
Jane Rusbridge, Author
Melanie Silgardo, Poet
Kitty Fitzgerald, Author
Amanda Mason, author
Doreen Milne
Amanda de Lussey
Patricia Knibb
Julia Williams, Author
Ava Marsh, Author
Ellen Phethean, Poet and YA Author
Jane MacKenzie
Lynn Alderson
J Gourley
Sara Bailey, Author and Lecturer (UHI)
Umi Sinha, Author
Julian Vigo PhD, Scholar and Writer
Issy Dickinson, UK Feminist Writer and Activist
Jo Bartosch, Writer and Women’s Rights Campaigner
Libby Emmons, writer
Jon Cook, Professor of Literature, University of East Anglia
Dr. Madeleine Jowett, formerly University of Aberdeen
Bo Novak
Kim Harding
Denise Prideaux
Jean Hatchet, Women’s Rights Campaigner
Dr. Debbie Hayton, Teacher of Physics
Deborah Evans, English Teacher
Alison Owen, Film and TV Producer
Rebecca Johnson, Writer/Director
Grace Carley
Liz Pitt
Dr Viv Pointon
Jan Taylor
William Hale, Librarian
Kasha Dalal, Thinker
Jill Nesbit
Janet Pontin
Erika Luukas
Stella O’Malley
Amina Lone, Writer and Researcher
Rita Rake
Ann-Marie Stacey
Sarah Anderson
Charlotte Delaney
Valerie Reltie
Simon Edge
Bea Jaspert
Seani Hansen
Lucy Winters, Teacher
Ann Mclure, Retired Teacher
Jennifer Milligan, Librarian
Ginny Dougary
Jonny Best, Musician and Festival Director
Dr Angela Mansi
Laetitia Pichevin Harrison
Ophelia Benson
Sam Davey, Director, Hastings Literary Festival
Jo Tracy, Script Editor
Anne Cater, Book Blogger
Josephine Liptrott
Pilgrim Tucker
Jackie Mearns
Thain Parnell, Journalist and Feminist Activist
Shernaz Dinshaw
Ms. Joanna Campbell
Rose Sanders
Louise Paine
Rhona Hotchkiss, former Prison Governor
Kristina Jane Harrison, Frontline NHS Worker
Alessandra Asteriti
Ann Sinnott
Kath Ball BA MA
Alice Bondi, Retired Psychotherapist
Miranda Yardley FCA CTA
Janey Hutton, Self-Employed
Barbara Hughes
Leslie Gray O’Neil
Hazel Pegg, Green Party Executive Member
Natalie Bird
Louise Webster
Many Harkness
Karen Varley
Susan Ram
Caroline Foster
Michelle Yanas
Iain Ingram
Dr Lesley Semmens
Professor Kirstein Rummery
Suzanne Kimm
Elizabeth Speller
Carter Sheard
Anna Morvern
Annette Gordon
A.M. Scanlon
S. J. Atherton
Maggie McShane
Dr Louisa Tsongaraki
Harriet Smart
Miki Brunt
Susan Elliot Wright
Lucy Ward
Anne James
Trini Couldrey
Réaltán Ní Leannáin
Andreia Nobre
Pippa Banham
Brenda Ellis
Mary Howden
Dr Ailsa Holland
Lorraine Nut
M. Gadd
Heather Binning
Tony Rose
@manymiaows
Cheryl Graham
Mary Gordon
Susan Stowe
Sharon Jenkins
Gina Scot
Christine Kearney
Joanna Green
Anna Brockman
Paul Tracy
Morven McGill
Miriam C. Richards
Peter Magellan
Juliet Dire
Teresa Willis
Pat Arnott
Julie Scott
Julie Smith
@vicbikechick
Irene Soldatas
Darrell Rivers
@andreeaaaaa
@KeithN2020
Edwina Wolstencroft
Jennifer Griffiths
Mackinnon@bnipotd
Lorraine@lorraineanneha1
Julie-Ann Corrigan
Sarah Cummings
Elle Seivewright
Claire Graham
Rachel Rooney, teacher and poet
Jessie L. Mannisto
Maggie Mellon, Edinburgh
Lesley Reeves
Madeleine Kearns
Kalesi Wolf
@ImHowardBeale1
Delyth Rennie
Andrea Jones, journalist
Georgina Wheatley
Annie Robinson
Caroline Horn
Sharon Muench
Tracy Kershaw
Lorraine McIntosh
Patricia Spencer
Caroline Horne
Patricia Spencer
Pat McGoverne
Kate Tym
Ros Olleson
Rita Balneaves
Meg Baglow
Angelina Melwani
Georgina Farron
Marianne Madill
Susie Harris
Helen Cummins
Heather Welford, writer
Heather Finlay
Michelle Smart
Dr. C Marshall
Jane Hutton
Debbie Black
Sarah McGurk
Catriona MacInnes
Liz Houchin
Julie Bindel
Doreen Dunne
Jane Kavanagh
Euan Johnston
Helen Saxby
Seonaid Dawn Barber
Silvia Beck
Leena Jones
Carol Archer
Tess Joseph
Sarah Takahashi
Angela Stewart-Park
Sarah Honeychurch, University of Glasgow
Nathalie Houle
Robert Dawson Scott
Nathalie Houle
Fodo Higginson
Anna Hillier
Michelle Johnson
Olly Lambert
Cristina Mindroiu
Lisa Randall
R Irischild
Carol Fraser
Lara Alberts
Karen Bresner
Lisa jones
Saskia Bennett
Ann Haigh
Sarah Crofts
Tiffany Jenkins
Sue Thorne
Sandra Price
Diana Peek
Anne Wilson
Jess De Wahls, Artist
Dr Rowan Aust
Matt Seattle
Clarissa Payne
Catherine Hill
Ellen Stagg
Beth Miller
Carly Brooks
Bec Wonders
Sharon Hunter
Wendy Thomson
Stephen Cohen
Yvonne Alexis
Jane Cooper
Fred Sargeant
Professor Kathleen Stock, University of Sussex
Tiffany Jenkins
Esther Giles
Rebecca Harrison
M. Lindsay
Charlotte Roberts
Jacqueline Bale
Rebecca D
Gabrielle Sinclair
Miriam Yagud
Cath Ferguson
Clare O’Neill
Meg Edgoose-Clubley
Louise M Thorburn
Maureen Pickering
Shirley Wishart
@DelizaDoolittle
Gina Burton
Dr B Reay
Wendy Martin
Cee M. Reilly
Mags Hodge
Amanda Samuels
Graham Boyd
Mark Ryle
Lisa Clark
Eddie
Bernie Mayall
Charlotte Edwards
Anna Caro
Steven Gray
Dougie McLean
Heather Moore
Louise Somerville
Dr Peter R Ashby BSc PhD
Gordon Dangerfield
Jacqueline McMillan
Fiona Savage
Jess Monck
Rory Waterman
Jill Simmons, QMU President 1984/5
Iain Macwhirter
Nerissa Pace
Marian Coyne
Raymond Soltysek
Claire Gibbs
Leonora Christina
Meg Dellatana
Alison Wren
Fiona Thomson
Margaret Hinchcliffe
Dr A Robertson
Claire Gibbs
Diane Holyoak
Linda Knowles
Susan Smith, co-convener of ForwomenScot
Mary McAuley
Trezza Azzopardi
Georgina Kuna
Jennifer Hill, writer and former newspaper journalist
Benedict
Terry Hobday
Dr Diane Brewster
Dawn Thatcher
Madeleine Morey
Sadhana Stone
Rae Livingstone
Chantel Mathias
Geraldine Adams
Lorna Gradden
Christine Somers
Jane Clare
Lorna Gradden
Fiona Mitchell
John Yorke
Anne McConville
Nancy Power
Nicola Burkinshaw
Eileen Fingleton
Deb Cox
Annett Kottek
Lisa Thompson
K Taylor
Gerry Robinson
Andi Chapple
Sibyl Ruth
Irene Aristizábal
E.Evans
Allison McDonald
Sue Harris
Cheryl Angle
Chris M
Sarah Gellner
Chris Batey
Seán Martin
Abigail Elizabeth Ottley (teacher and poet)
Hugh Meechan
Helan McMahon
Anne R Kerr
Emma Taverner
Carina Moravec
Lucy Lawrence
Clara Childerley
Bibbit Blair
Dave Jones
Margaret O’Neill
Fay Boans
Jane Irving
Joolz Denby
Anne Marie McGeehin
Mickey McCarthy
Helen Freeborn
Jane Robertson
Janet Wright
Trish Sims, teacher
Jo Kneale, Mother, daughter, wife: Woman
Jane Doe, Writer and lecturer, anonymous for safety reasons
Freddie Brougham
Susan King
Graeme Watt
Gail Ess
Anne Conner
K. Bird, artist, writer, filmmaker
Sara White
Joanne Priest
Victoria Lygo
Katie, Mental health nurse
Caterina Santa Cruz
Willie Clark
Jane Kidd
Elaine Coates
Alison Jenner
Lorraine Mondo
Nancy Shaw
Margaret Paris
Paul Bowen
Sue Harris
Word Respect
Abigail Elizabeth Rowland
Leese77
Jo Adams
Lola Casey
C.M. Brown
Vicky Miller
Susie Collcut
Raymond Mennie
Heather Jenkinson
Sophie Cook, writer
K Leigh
Huw Parker
Sarah Morrison
Sean
Carol Jenkins
Alice Heywood
Craig Porter
Joy Clifford
Geraldine Halpin
Amanda Williams
Jenni Russell
Hedy Watt MEng
Mary Wright
Tiffany Richardson
Ruth Conlock, social worker
Leigh Duncan, writer
Jane Choules
Kat Harvey
Fiona Vigar
Amanda Barefoot
Elizabeth Hamilton
M Parker
Mark Crocker
Merrilyn Wasson
Stevie
Carole Herbert
Kay Campbell
Julie Moss, freelance journalist
Mary Bain Lockhart, feminist
Jennifer Smith
Julian Whitley
Morwenna Lake
Jaine Cronin
Sam Brando
Cherry Wild
Colin Chalmers
Lynne Keys
Adrian Searle
Alistair Veitch
Peter Morgan
Michelle Houlden
Alistair Gorthy
Stephanie Pickering
Clare Page, Solicitor
Jo. B
Rosie Nesbitt
Molly Burgess
Rehana Rose
Maire McCormack
Alan Ryan
Sian Henry
Leslie McKitterick, English Teacher
Dr A. Dyce
Mrs Ann Fuller
Ewen Stewart
Maureen O’Hara
Jennifer van Leijen
Ian Hirst
Jo Drant
Jacqueline Chneour
Guy Lloyd
Gillian Philip, Author
Catherine Wright
Tamara Kennedy
Ellinor Westling
Marie Murphy
James Madden
Caroline Hepple
Loirna Irvine
Harry Owen
Neil Young, poet
Margaret Gribbon
Kate Alexander
Lisa Mackenzie
Robert Alcock
Margaret Nelson
Dawn Foster
Elizabeth Malcolm
Dr Brian McNeil
Jackie Bourke
Nicola Humphreys
Lucy Hunter Blackburn
Sarah Dunnakey
Les R.
Wendy Brindle
Jenni Bradbury
Jeremy Poynton
Dr Kathryn Turner
Richard Munro
Gordon Edward Newell
Daressa Mullen
Jane Callahan
Dr Sarah Smith
Tessa Pawsey
Click here to read the signatories’ comments
Add my name
Maggie Mellon Edinburgh
LikeLike
I don’t know how I missed this – too late to sign, but I agree wholeheartedly.
Paul Madill
Public Health Specialist
LikeLike
Please add my signature to the open letter.
LikeLike
Please add my name.
LikeLike
Will do, thanks Caroline
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Will do, thanks
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Will do, Kate
LikeLike
Please add my name.
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name; thank you.
– Jennifer Hill, writer and former newspaper journalist
LikeLike
I support this wholeheartedly. Please add my name. I am not an author or poet if that matters
LikeLike
Please add me. I’m fed up of being scared to speak out.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name. Thank you!
LikeLike
Please add my name.
LikeLike
Please add my name to this.
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Fully support the open letter.
LikeLike
Please add my name, Tiffany M Richardson
LikeLike
Please add my name:
K Leigh
LikeLike
Please add my name, Lorna Irvine
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
Charlotte Thorne
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
Please add my name
LikeLike
The very people who campaign for liberation from life- limiting, socially constructed gender roles, who oppose discrimination in all its forms and stand with people who face oppression, are being silenced and vilified.
How has it come to this?
How has an orthodoxy been allowed to take hold within a progressive movement?
Whose tune are we dancing to?
And how weakened do these divisions leave us when we attempt to counter real prejudice?
Respectful yet robust debate is crucial where the implcations of self identification and the challenge to the factual definition of our biological sex are so far reaching.
How else, but through legitimate expression and listening to one another, can we hope to move forward in ways that respect the humanity of each person and resolve the conflicting needs of different groups?
Thank you to the Scottish Poetry Library for your integrity and courageous stance.
LikeLiked by 1 person